The 5 Biggest Mistakes Out-of-State Buyers Make in Connecticut

The 5 Biggest Mistakes Out-of-State Buyers Make in Connecticut

Out-of-state buyers are some of my favorite clients. They ask good questions and they are not carrying any old assumptions about which town is "supposed" to be right for them. But in twenty years in Connecticut real estate, I have seen the same handful of mistakes come up again and again. Here they are, and how to avoid them.

1. Underestimating property taxes, and how much they vary by town

Connecticut towns rely heavily on property tax, and each one sets its own mill rate: tax dollars per $1,000 of assessed value. Two houses with the same price on opposite sides of a town line can carry very different tax bills.

How different? In the state's FY2027 mill rate data from the Office of Policy and Management, rates run from 9.8 in Salisbury and 10.125 in Greenwich up to 69.95 in Hartford. Most towns fall somewhere in between. When you are comparing homes, ask for the current assessment and multiply it by that town's current mill rate. Don't rely on the tax figure in an old listing, and remember that many towns also tax cars.

2. Not knowing that Connecticut closings run through attorneys

If you are coming from a state where a title or escrow company handles everything, Connecticut will feel different. The General Assembly's Office of Legislative Research notes that Connecticut statutes do not require buyers or sellers to hire an attorney, but an attorney's participation is likely required in most real estate transactions, including any involving title insurance.

In practice, you will want your own Connecticut real estate attorney lined up before you sign a contract. They review the contract, handle title, and run the closing. We have a separate post on Attorney Closings in Connecticut with the details.

3. Skipping the oil tank, well, septic and radon questions

A lot of Connecticut homes are older, and many are outside town water and sewer. That brings up questions buyers from newer suburbs may never have had to ask.

  • Oil tanks. If the house has, or ever had, a buried heating oil tank, ask whether it was removed and whether there is paperwork. The Department of Energy and Environmental Protection's homeowner FAQ points buyers to removal records, a report with lab results, and the local Fire Marshal's file. DEEP also notes that if soil tests show a tank leaked, the owner is responsible for the cleanup.
  • Private wells. The Department of Public Health highly recommends testing water quality when buying a home, and notes that bank-required tests are not required by law and may not cover all contaminants. DPH also recommends testing for arsenic, uranium and radon at least once.
  • Septic. Ask about the system's age, location and service history, and talk to your inspector about a septic evaluation. Your town health department may have records.
  • Radon. The Department of Public Health recommends that all Connecticut homes be tested for radon. In its 2023 release, DPH cited the EPA recommendation to fix homes at or above 4.0 pCi/L.

4. Ignoring the foundation concrete issue in north-central and eastern Connecticut

This one is specific to Connecticut and important. According to the state Department of Housing, upwards of 35,000 homes near Stafford Springs may have a failing concrete foundation because of pyrrhotite, a naturally occurring iron sulfide that slowly deteriorates concrete when exposed to oxygen and water.

The state's foundation testing reimbursement program covers homes within 20 miles of the J.J. Mottes Concrete Company in Stafford Springs that were built between January 1, 1983 and December 31, 2015, with some exceptions for later additions. There are two kinds of testing:

  • Visual inspection by a Connecticut-licensed professional engineer, who gives an opinion on whether the cracking is caused by the concrete mix.
  • Core testing, which takes a sample of the foundation to find out whether pyrrhotite is present and in what amount.

There is also a state-created insurer, the Connecticut Foundation Solutions Indemnity Company (CFSIC), that helps eligible owners pay for foundation replacement. Its underwriting criteria include a rule that matters for buyers: for buildings built in 1983 or later and purchased on or after February 1, 2019, the buyer or seller must have tested for pyrrhotite or had a visual exam before the sale. If you are looking anywhere in that part of the state, talk to your attorney and inspector about testing before you are locked in.

5. Not visiting at rush hour, or in winter

A Saturday afternoon showing in October tells you very little about a Tuesday commute in February. Before you commit, drive the route to work at the time you would actually leave. Look at the driveway and picture clearing it after a storm. Notice whether the street is a hill. If you can, come back once when the weather is bad.

A better way to start

None of these issues should scare you off Connecticut. They are just the homework that comes with older homes and a town-by-town tax system. And if the right house is not on the market, we can help you find one with upside potential and transform it into the house you actually want.

If you are weighing a move to Connecticut and want a straight answer about a specific town, a specific house, or what a day of commuting really looks like, call or text me at (860) 830-8996. I am happy to talk it through, no pressure.

— Wayne Watt Jr., Broker/Owner, The Connecticut Agency, LLC

Sources

Figures checked October 2026. Rates and fees change; confirm current numbers with the town or your attorney.

Work With Us

Whether you’re relocating, transitioning, or planning a future move, We offer expert guidance and a full range of services. Let’s make your next move a success!

Follow Us on Instagram