A lot of the calls I get from New York start the same way: "We love the city, but we want more room." Connecticut can be a great answer to that. It can also be the wrong answer if you only hear the good parts. I have been selling homes in Connecticut since 2005, so here is the honest version.
Pro: No city income tax layered on top
If you live in New York City today, you pay New York City personal income tax on top of state tax. Connecticut has a state income tax, but no city-level income tax on top of it. Connecticut cities and towns rely on the property tax as their main local revenue source, which I will get to in a minute.
Connecticut's income tax rates for the 2024 tax year and after run from 2% to 6.99%, according to the General Assembly's Office of Legislative Research. For single filers, the 2% rate covers the first $10,000 of taxable income and the top 6.99% rate applies over $500,000. For joint filers, those thresholds are $20,000 and $1,000,000.
One important wrinkle: if you keep working in New York after you move, New York can still tax the income you earn there. New York's tax department says nonresidents with New York-source income may still have to file a New York State return, and that nonresidents of New York City are not liable for New York City personal income tax. Connecticut, in turn, generally gives residents a credit for income taxes paid to another state on the same income. How that nets out for your household is a question for your CPA, not your real estate agent.
Con: Property taxes are real, and they vary a lot by town
This is where New Yorkers sometimes get surprised. Connecticut property tax is set town by town as a mill rate: dollars of tax per $1,000 of assessed value. Your bill is the property's assessed value times that rate.
The spread is wide. In the state's FY2027 mill rate data, published by the Office of Policy and Management, Greenwich's rate is 10.125, Stamford's is 28.47, and Hartford's is 69.95. Same state, very different tax bills on a similarly priced house. Before you fall in love with a listing, look up that town's current mill rate and the property's assessment on the town assessor's site.
Pro: You can still get to the city by train
For many of my New York buyers, the train is the deciding factor. According to the Connecticut Department of Transportation, Metro-North's New Haven Line runs from New Haven Union Station to Grand Central Terminal, and it also serves the New Canaan, Danbury and Waterbury branch lines.
Farther north, CTrail's Hartford Line connects New Haven, Hartford and Springfield, Massachusetts, along the I-91 corridor, with transfers at New Haven to the New Haven Line, Amtrak and Shore Line East. That means Hartford County is not cut off from New York, but it is a longer trip with a connection. If you will be commuting several days a week, ride it at rush hour before you buy. Schedules and travel times change, so check the current timetables yourself rather than trusting what a friend did five years ago.
Con: Driving is part of life here
Outside of a handful of downtowns, Connecticut is a driving state. Groceries, school pickups, the hardware store: most of it happens by car. If you are giving up a no-car life, budget for at least one vehicle, insurance and, yes, Connecticut also taxes motor vehicles locally. Some towns use a different mill rate for cars than for homes, so check both.
Pro: More house, more yard, more breathing room
I am not going to quote you price-per-square-foot comparisons, because those numbers move and depend completely on which neighborhood you are comparing. What I will say is that most of the New York buyers I talk to are looking for the same things: a real yard, a garage, a basement for storage, and a quieter street. Connecticut's housing stock, from older colonials and capes to newer construction, gives you a lot of ways to get there.
Good to know: Attorneys handle closings here
In New York you are probably used to attorneys being involved in a purchase. Connecticut is similar in practice. The Office of Legislative Research notes that while Connecticut statutes do not require buyers or sellers to hire an attorney, an attorney's participation is likely required in most real estate transactions, including any that involve title insurance. Practically speaking, plan on having your own Connecticut attorney. We have a separate guide on Attorney Closings in Connecticut if you want the step-by-step.
Con: The houses are older, and older houses have homework
Much of Connecticut's housing stock has some age to it. That is a big part of the charm, and it also means oil tanks, wells, septic systems and radon come up more than they do in a city co-op. None of it is a deal-breaker. It just means you want a good inspector and a broker who knows which questions to ask.
And one more thing I tell every buyer: if we cannot find the exact house you want, we can look at a house with upside potential and transform it into the right house for you. Sometimes the best fit is not on the market yet in finished form.
The bottom line
Connecticut gives a lot of New Yorkers what they are missing: space, a slower pace and a reasonable path back to the city. The trade-offs are property tax, more time in the car and a little more homework on older homes. Go in with clear eyes and it can be one of the best moves you make.
If you are weighing a move to Connecticut and want a straight answer about a specific town, a specific house, or what a day of commuting really looks like, call or text me at (860) 830-8996. I am happy to talk it through, no pressure.
— Wayne Watt Jr., Broker/Owner, The Connecticut Agency, LLC
Sources
- Connecticut General Assembly, OLR — A Guide to Connecticut's Personal Income Tax (2024-R-0130)
- NYS Department of Taxation and Finance — Nonresident FAQs
- NYS Department of Taxation and Finance — 2024 tax tables (NYC resident tax)
- Hartford Business Journal — CT municipal leaders call for local taxes
- CT Open Data (OPM) — Mill Rates for FY 2014-2027
- CT DOT — CTrail passenger rail service
- CT DOT — Hartford Line stations
- Connecticut General Assembly, OLR — Attorneys at Real Estate Closings in Connecticut and Massachusetts
Figures checked October 2026. Rates and fees change; confirm current numbers with the town or your attorney.