Avon, Simsbury and Farmington sit side by side in the Farmington Valley, share a river and a trail network, and often show up on the same buyer's shortlist. People ask me which one is "best." The honest answer is that none of them is best — they're different, and the right one depends on what you'll actually use day to day. Here's a side-by-side look built on verified numbers, organized around the priorities that tend to decide it.
The quick numbers
From the Census Bureau's boundary files and its 2020–2024 American Community Survey:
- Avon: about 23 square miles of land, roughly 18,950 residents.
- Farmington: about 28 square miles, roughly 27,100 residents.
- Simsbury: about 34 square miles, roughly 25,100 residents.
And from the state Office of Policy and Management's mill rate dataset, the FY2027 real estate mill rates (grand list 2025):
- Farmington: 27.36
- Avon: 31.8
- Simsbury: 33.67, plus a Simsbury Fire District levy of 1.33 mills
Two cautions. First, a lower mill rate doesn't automatically mean a lower tax bill — the bill depends on the assessed value of the specific house, which in Connecticut is 70% of market value. Second, Avon and Farmington both have small special tax districts in certain neighborhoods. Always compare the actual bill on the actual house, and have your attorney confirm it.
If your priority is highway access
Farmington is the one with I-84 inside its borders, which matters if you're heading toward Hartford, Waterbury or west. Avon is organized around U.S. Route 44, which crosses Avon Mountain into West Hartford, and U.S. Route 202. Simsbury's main spine is Route 10/202 running north-south through its villages. Rather than trust anyone's drive-time estimate, do the drive at the hour you'd actually commute.
If your priority is trails and open space
All three are on the Farmington Canal Heritage Trail. The trail association describes the canal trail and the Farmington River Trail together as a 28.5-mile loop through five towns, and both Farmington and Simsbury sit on that loop.
- Avon: the town lists a 4.5-mile section of the greenway in Avon, plus large town parcels like Fisher Meadows (about 250 acres) and Huckleberry Hill Recreation Area (about 280 acres).
- Simsbury: the town says it maintains more than 1,600 acres of parks and open space, including the 235-acre Simsbury Farms complex, and it's home to Talcott Mountain State Park and Heublein Tower, Stratton Brook State Park and the McLean Game Refuge.
- Farmington: Tunxis Mead along the river, Westwoods Golf Course, Suburban Park in Unionville and more than 300 acres protected by the Farmington Land Trust.
If your priority is a village center
- Farmington has two: the historic village along Main Street and Unionville's center along the river.
- Simsbury is really four villages — Simsbury Center, Weatogue, Tariffville and West Simsbury — with Hopmeadow Street as the main downtown.
- Avon is laid out around its main roads, U.S. Routes 44 and 202, with sections like West Avon in the flatter middle of town and the Buckingham area up on Woodford Hill. It feels more spread out than the other two.
If your priority is a particular kind of house
The Census Bureau's 2020–2024 survey shows how each town's housing breaks down:
- Share of detached single-family homes: Simsbury about 72%, Avon about 72%, Farmington about 65%.
- Townhouses and other attached units: Avon about 11%, Farmington about 10%, Simsbury about 4%.
- Biggest building decades: Avon's housing peaks in the 1970s and 1980s (together nearly half the stock). Simsbury's peaks in the 1960s and 1970s. Farmington's largest decade is the 1980s, and it also has the biggest share of pre-1940 homes of the three, at about 10%.
In practical terms: if you want an antique or a home near a historic district, Farmington gives you the most to choose from. If you want a 1960s–70s colonial or ranch to update, Simsbury has a deep supply. If you want 1970s–80s colonials and contemporaries or a townhouse, Avon is strong. All three have condos and newer construction in smaller numbers.
Housing you'll find there
Across all three towns, expect mostly colonials, capes, ranches and raised ranches on suburban lots, with townhouse and condo communities mixed in and a modest amount of construction since 2000. The houses I see most often in the Valley were built between the 1960s and 1980s. They tend to be well built and roomy, but often dated inside. That's where the "90% work" — paint, caulk, floors, lighting, hardware — makes the biggest difference, both for enjoying the home now and when it's eventually time to sell.
Which fits your priorities?
- Commute: Need I-84? Start in Farmington. Commuting via Route 44 toward West Hartford? Look at Avon. Comfortable with Route 10/202 as your main road? Simsbury is worth a look.
- Lot size: All three have a range. The western and outer parts of each town generally offer more land; the village areas trade yard for walkability.
- Budget: Compare the full annual tax bill on specific houses, including any fire or special district charge, plus insurance and likely updates.
- Town services: Look at which parks, pools, golf courses, libraries and programs you'd actually use, and how close they are to the house.
For school information on any of these towns, use the Connecticut State Department of Education's EdSight portal and contact each district directly.
If you're torn between Avon, Simsbury and Farmington, call or text me at (860) 830-8996. We can tour all three in an afternoon, and if the right house isn't on the market, we'll look for one with upside potential and make it the right one.
— Wayne Watt Jr., Broker/Owner, The Connecticut Agency, LLC
Sources
- CT Office of Policy and Management via CT Open Data — Mill Rates dataset (FY2027 / Grand List 2025)
- CT General Assembly, Office of Legislative Research — Property Revaluation (2012-R-0098), 70% assessment rule
- U.S. Census Bureau ACS 2020–2024 5-year (via Census Reporter) — Avon town, CT profile
- U.S. Census Bureau ACS 2020–2024 5-year (via Census Reporter) — Farmington town, CT profile
- U.S. Census Bureau ACS 2020–2024 5-year (via Census Reporter) — Simsbury town, CT profile
- Town of Avon — Parks, Facilities & Rentals
- Town of Simsbury — Parks and Recreation
- Town of Simsbury — Simsbury Parks
- Town of Farmington — Farmington Valley multi-use trails
- Farmington Libraries — 36 Hours in Farmington and Unionville
- Farmington Canal Heritage Trail Association — About the trail
- Wikipedia — Avon, Connecticut (roads, sections)
Figures checked October 2026. Rates and fees change; confirm current numbers with the town or your attorney.